Buying Physical Gold: Coins vs Bars and What Actually Holds Value

A
Amanda Foster
November 23, 20255 min read

Bottom Line

The markup between gold coins and bars can hit 30% - here's which form makes sense for your specific situation.

Gold is trading at $2,050 per ounce, but you'll never pay that price. Dealers charge premiums based on the form you buy, and the difference between a smart purchase and an expensive mistake comes down to understanding what you're actually paying for.

Bars carry the lowest premiums - typically 2-5% over spot price for popular sizes like 1 oz, 10 oz, and 100 oz. You're paying for pure metal with minimal fabrication cost. Coins run 5-10% over spot for government-minted bullion like American Eagles or Canadian Maples. Collectible or numismatic coins can hit 30-50% premiums, and that extra cost rarely recovers when you sell.

The case for bars is simple math. If you're buying $10,000 in gold at a 3% premium, you start with $9,709 in actual metal. At a 10% coin premium, you start with $9,091 in metal. That $618 difference means gold needs to appreciate 6.8% just to break even with the bar purchase. For pure wealth preservation, bars win.

Coins have one advantage - liquidity. You can sell three 1 oz coins easier than one 3 oz bar. For emergency situations where you need quick cash, coins give you flexibility to sell only what you need.

The smart strategy combines both. Keep 25-30% in coins for liquidity, 70-75% in bars for lower premiums. Stick to standard sizes that dealers recognize - 1 oz bars, 10 oz bars, American Eagles, and Canadian Maples. Avoid obscure private mints or odd weights that dealers discount heavily when you sell.

Storage costs matter as much as premiums. A bank safe deposit box runs $50-200/year and provides zero insurance. Home safes under $1,000 don't stop determined thieves. Allocated storage at a dealer-affiliated vault costs 0.5-1% annually but includes $100,000+ insurance. For holdings over $25,000, professional storage pays for itself in reduced anxiety alone.

Logo

APMEX Gold Products

4.6
  • Massive inventory selection
  • Low premiums on bulk orders
  • Buyback program guaranteed
  • Secure vault storage available
Shop Gold
Logo

JM Bullion

4.7
  • Competitive pricing on bars
  • Free shipping over $199
  • Easy online ordering
  • IRA-eligible products
View Prices
Logo

SD Bullion

4.5
  • Lowest premium guarantees
  • Government-minted coins in stock
  • Volume discounts available
  • Same-day shipping on orders
Compare Options

Disclaimer: The information provided on this page is for informational purposes only. All offers are subject to change and may not be available in all areas. Please verify eligibility and terms with each provider.

Share this article

Get More Money-Saving Tips

Join thousands of readers getting expert money tips delivered to their inbox weekly.

Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your privacy.